Multi-Agent Debate

PR Ready

Structured debate with pro/con agents, moderator synthesis, and human judgment.

7 nodes · 7 edgespr ready

autogenmulti-agentdebatereasoning

Visual

Pose Debate Questionhuman

User provides the debate topic and any constraints.

↓sequential→ Moderator — Opening

Moderator — Openingagent

Frames the question, defines scope, and sets debate rules.

↓parallel→ Pro Agent

↓parallel→ Con Agent

Pro Agentagent

Argues in favor of the proposition with evidence and reasoning.

↓sequential→ Rebuttal Round

Con Agentagent

Argues against the proposition with counterevidence.

↓sequential→ Rebuttal Round

Rebuttal Roundagent

Both agents respond to the other's arguments (2 iterations).

↓sequential→ Moderator — Synthesis

Moderator — Synthesisagent

Summarizes both sides, highlights strongest arguments and gaps.

↓sequential→ Human Judge

Human Judgehuman

Reviews the debate transcript and declares a winner or draw.

Open in Editor

ex-autogen-debate.osop.yaml

# AutoGen Multi-Agent Debate — OSOP Portable Workflow
#
# A structured debate between AI agents: a moderator poses a question,
# pro and con agents argue in parallel, the moderator synthesizes both
# sides, and a human judge delivers the final verdict.
#
# Run with AutoGen or validate: osop validate autogen-debate.osop.yaml

osop_version: "1.0"
id: "autogen-debate"
name: "Multi-Agent Debate"
description: "Structured debate with pro/con agents, moderator synthesis, and human judgment."
version: "1.0.0"
tags: [autogen, multi-agent, debate, reasoning]

nodes:
  - id: "pose_question"
    type: "human"
    name: "Pose Debate Question"
    description: "User provides the debate topic and any constraints."

  - id: "moderator_open"
    type: "agent"
    subtype: "llm"
    name: "Moderator — Opening"
    description: "Frames the question, defines scope, and sets debate rules."
    config:
      role: "Neutral Moderator"
      model: "gpt-4o"

  - id: "pro_agent"
    type: "agent"
    subtype: "llm"
    name: "Pro Agent"
    description: "Argues in favor of the proposition with evidence and reasoning."
    config:
      role: "Proponent"
      tools: [web_search, cite_source]

  - id: "con_agent"
    type: "agent"
    subtype: "llm"
    name: "Con Agent"
    description: "Argues against the proposition with counterevidence."
    config:
      role: "Opponent"
      tools: [web_search, cite_source]

  - id: "rebuttal_round"
    type: "agent"
    subtype: "llm"
    name: "Rebuttal Round"
    description: "Both agents respond to the other's arguments (2 iterations)."
    config:
      max_iterations: 2

  - id: "moderator_synthesize"
    type: "agent"
    subtype: "llm"
    name: "Moderator — Synthesis"
    description: "Summarizes both sides, highlights strongest arguments and gaps."

  - id: "human_judge"
    type: "human"
    subtype: "review"
    name: "Human Judge"
    description: "Reviews the debate transcript and declares a winner or draw."

edges:
  - from: "pose_question"
    to: "moderator_open"
    mode: "sequential"
  - from: "moderator_open"
    to: "pro_agent"
    mode: "parallel"
  - from: "moderator_open"
    to: "con_agent"
    mode: "parallel"
  - from: "pro_agent"
    to: "rebuttal_round"
    mode: "sequential"
  - from: "con_agent"
    to: "rebuttal_round"
    mode: "sequential"
  - from: "rebuttal_round"
    to: "moderator_synthesize"
    mode: "sequential"
  - from: "moderator_synthesize"
    to: "human_judge"
    mode: "sequential"

←

ML Training Pipeline

Research Pipeline Crew

→