學術同儕審查

Human ↔ Human

學術論文從投稿、編輯初審、平行同儕審查、修訂迴圈到出版的完整流程。

6 個節點 · 7 條連接education

human

視覺化

投稿論文human

作者透過編輯系統向期刊投稿手稿。

↓sequential→ 編輯初審

編輯初審human

總編輯篩選論文範疇、品質及格式要求。

↓parallel→ 審稿人 A

↓parallel→ 審稿人 B

審稿人 Ahuman

第一位同儕審稿人評估研究方法、成果與貢獻。

↓sequential→ 編輯決定

審稿人 Bhuman

第二位同儕審稿人提供獨立評估與建議。

↓sequential→ 編輯決定

編輯決定human

編輯綜合審查意見並做出決定：接受、修訂或退稿。

↓conditional→ 出版

↓loop→ 投稿論文

出版system

已接受的論文完成排版、分配 DOI 並上線發布。

在編輯器開啟

uc-peer-review.osop.yaml

osop_version: "1.0"
id: "peer-review"
name:"學術同儕審查"
description:"學術論文從投稿、編輯初審、平行同儕審查、修訂迴圈到出版的完整流程。"

nodes:
  - id: "submit_paper"
    type: "human"
    subtype: "input"
    name: "投稿論文"
    description: "作者透過編輯系統向期刊投稿手稿。"

  - id: "editorial_screen"
    type: "human"
    subtype: "review"
    name: "編輯初審"
    description: "總編輯篩選論文範疇、品質及格式要求。"

  - id: "reviewer_a"
    type: "human"
    subtype: "review"
    name: "審稿人 A"
    description: "第一位同儕審稿人評估研究方法、成果與貢獻。"

  - id: "reviewer_b"
    type: "human"
    subtype: "review"
    name: "審稿人 B"
    description: "第二位同儕審稿人提供獨立評估與建議。"

  - id: "editor_decision"
    type: "human"
    subtype: "review"
    name: "編輯決定"
    description: "編輯綜合審查意見並做出決定：接受、修訂或退稿。"

  - id: "publish"
    type: "system"
    subtype: "action"
    name: "出版"
    description: "已接受的論文完成排版、分配 DOI 並上線發布。"

edges:
  - from: "submit_paper"
    to: "editorial_screen"
    mode: "sequential"
  - from: "editorial_screen"
    to: "reviewer_a"
    mode: "parallel"
  - from: "editorial_screen"
    to: "reviewer_b"
    mode: "parallel"
  - from: "reviewer_a"
    to: "editor_decision"
    mode: "sequential"
  - from: "reviewer_b"
    to: "editor_decision"
    mode: "sequential"
  - from: "editor_decision"
    to: "publish"
    mode: "conditional"
    when: "decision == 'accept'"
  - from: "editor_decision"
    to: "submit_paper"
    mode: "loop"
    when: "decision == 'revise'"
    label: "Revisions requested"